Friday, January 18, 2013

New Poll Opened: Do We Need Positive Virtual Law?

Dear readers, my late congratulations on winter holidays! Thanks to everyone who occasionally visits this blog. Please be informed that I am still alive and well, just focused on the research of Internet and virtual law with a hope of publication in the end.

During this research I stumbled upon a couple of Russian court decisions which clearly fall within the scope of virtual law. A player sued major Russian MMORPG company asking for a compensation of money spent for two weeks of server downtime, money spent on a temporary virtual item which effectively lasted three days less than declared and, as usual, moral damages.

The first instance court (and higher courts as well) dismissed the claim on the grounds that such kind of relations in general are not governed by law, as they relate to rules of game. Note that there is a clause in the Russian Civil Code which states that relations deriving from a game are not enforceable unless the person participated in the game under coercion, fraud etc. or it was a kind of lottery with declared prizes. The reference to one of the cases for those Russian-speaking readers who are interested in the topic: Определение Басманного районного суда г. Москвы от 01.06.2011 г. по делу № 11-43/11 и делу № 11-115/09. You may find it via

Meanwhile, I welcome everyone to participate in a new simple poll on the right hand side of your screen. If there are at least two votes cast (unlike one during previous poll), I would be as happy as a clam at high tide.


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. I think you should actually make the poll a little more complicated (not sure if you agree, though). For example, you could ask *which* aspects of online mmorpg gaming should be regulated by positive law. Someone may think that bans are rather obvious, but in the same time feel that their privacy should be better protected (hence legal regulations), or maybe that trade of virtual objects should be possible anytime and that law should enhance it.

    1. Thank you for the comment! I totally agree with this and will make a more detailed poll when I come back to this topic.